ai-personas-critique
by magfrump
Critically review a proposal, design, or argument using dynamically selected AI criticism personas. Unlike cowen-critique and yglesias-critique (which apply a fixed voice), this skill selects 3-4 maximally orthogonal personas from a catalog of 17 based on the proposal's domain, runs each persona's objection, and synthesizes findings. This surfaces concerns that no single fixed-perspective critic would raise. Use this skill when the user wants diverse critical perspectives on a proposal, when cowen/yglesias perspectives feel too narrow for the subject matter, or when the user says things like "what am I missing", "stress-test this from multiple angles", "give me diverse critiques", "who would object to this and why", or "poke holes in this proposal". Also trigger when reviewing proposals that span multiple domains (e.g., technical + policy + organizational) where a single critic lens would miss important angles. NOTE: This skill is designed to complement cowen-critique and yglesias-critique, not replace them. Those skills provide deep, consistent voices. This skill provides breadth and surprise.