nirholas

crypto-governance-guide

Guide to DAO governance — voting mechanics (token-weighted, veToken, quadratic), proposal processes, delegation, and governance participation best practices. Covers Snapshot, on-chain governance, and real examples including Sperax, Aave, and Uniswap.

nirholas 247 69 Updated 5mo ago
GitHub

Install

npx skillscat add nirholas/three-ws/crypto-governance-guide

Install via the SkillsCat registry.

SKILL.md

Crypto Governance Guide

DAOs (Decentralized Autonomous Organizations) use various governance models to make protocol decisions. This guide helps AI agents assist users with governance participation.

Governance Models

Token-Weighted Voting

Most common model: 1 token = 1 vote.

Protocol Token Voting Platform
Uniswap UNI On-chain + Snapshot
Aave AAVE/stkAAVE On-chain
Compound COMP On-chain

Pros: Simple, aligns economic incentives
Cons: Whale-dominated, low participation

Vote-Escrowed (veToken)

Lock tokens for governance power. Longer lock = more power.

Protocol Token Lock Period Power Formula
Sperax SPA → veSPA 7d–4y veSPA = SPA × (days/365)
Curve CRV → veCRV 1w–4y veCRV = CRV × (days/365)
Balancer BAL → veBAL 1w–1y veBAL = BAL × (days/365)

Pros: Aligns long-term incentives, reduces mercenary governance
Cons: Capital lock-up, decaying voting power

Quadratic Voting

Vote weight = √(tokens). Reduces whale dominance.

Protocol Implementation
Gitcoin Quadratic funding for grants

Pros: More egalitarian
Cons: Sybil-vulnerable without identity verification

Optimistic Governance

Proposals pass unless vetoed within a timeframe.

Protocol Implementation
Optimism Token House + Citizens' House

Pros: Faster execution, less voter fatigue
Cons: Requires active monitoring

Governance Lifecycle

Typical Process

Idea → Discussion → Proposal → Vote → Execution

Sperax Governance (Example)

Phase Action Duration
Phase 0 Discord ideation Open-ended
Phase 1 Forum SIP proposal 48h minimum discussion
Phase 2 Snapshot vote 3 days, veSPA-weighted
Phase 3 Engineering implementation Varies

Requirements:

Aave Governance (Example)

Step Action
ARC Aave Request for Comments (forum)
AIP Aave Improvement Proposal (formal)
Vote On-chain vote (AAVE + stkAAVE weighted)
Timelock 24h delay before execution
Execute Automated on-chain execution

Voting Platforms

Snapshot (Off-Chain)

  • What: Gasless voting via signed messages
  • Used by: Most DAOs for governance votes
  • Cost: Free (no gas to vote)
  • Security: Relies on social consensus for execution

On-Chain Governance

  • What: Votes recorded on blockchain
  • Used by: Compound, Aave, Uniswap (binding votes)
  • Cost: Gas for each vote
  • Security: Enforced by smart contracts

Tally

  • What: Governance dashboard for on-chain proposals
  • Used by: Compound, Aave, Uniswap, and many others
  • URL: https://tally.xyz

Delegation

Many DAOs allow vote delegation — give your voting power to a delegate who votes on your behalf.

How It Works

  1. Choose a delegate whose values align with yours
  2. Delegate your voting power (you keep your tokens)
  3. Delegate votes on proposals on your behalf
  4. You can undelegate at any time

Benefits

  • For voters: Don't need to track every proposal
  • For DAOs: Higher effective participation
  • For delegates: Build reputation in governance

Proposal Analysis

When helping users evaluate proposals, consider:

Impact Assessment

Factor Questions
Scope How big is this change?
Risk What could go wrong?
Reversibility Can it be undone?
Precedent Does it set a precedent?
Economic Impact How does it affect token holders?

Red Flags in Proposals

  • Extremely short voting periods
  • Vague or poorly specified changes
  • Large treasury spending without detailed budget
  • Changes that benefit proposer disproportionately
  • Governance parameter changes (quorum, timelock)
  • Emergency proposals without clear emergency

Agent Tips

  1. Explain the proposal in plain language before recommending a vote
  2. Check quorum requirements — if a vote won't reach quorum, it doesn't matter
  3. Review discussion — what did the community say in forums?
  4. Delegation — recommend delegates for users who can't track every vote
  5. veToken mechanics — explain the lock-up tradeoff (more power vs less liquidity)
  6. Sperax governance — SPA → veSPA with weekly rewards makes governance participation profitable

Links

Categories