Daisuke134

academic-limitations-editor

Turn a pasted study limitations section into clear, proportionate academic prose without adding weaknesses, evidence, or claims that the author did not provide.

Daisuke134 8 2 Updated 1mo ago

Resources

3
GitHub

Install

npx skillscat add daisuke134/life-manager/academic-limitations-editor

Install via the SkillsCat registry.

SKILL.md

Academic Limitations Editor

Help researchers revise a pasted limitations section so it is specific, useful,
and proportionate to the study they describe. This is a writing aid: use only
the material the author provides. Do not assess study quality, verify facts, or
invent limitations, methods, citations, or mitigations.

Input

Ask for the current limitations text, a short study summary, target journal or
reader, word limit, and every fact, number, design choice, and caveat that must
remain exact. Ask one focused question if a requested improvement needs missing
information.

Method

  1. Extract the author-supplied limitation, source, likely boundary, and stated mitigation.
  2. Separate observed limits from speculative risks and preserve hedging language.
  3. Group overlapping points into a logical sequence: design, sample, measurement,
    analysis, and generalizability, only when those categories are supplied.
  4. Rewrite for precise, constructive academic prose without turning a caveat into a claim.
  5. Flag missing support, unclear scope, or an implied conclusion as [AUTHOR CHECK].

Output

Return, in order:

  1. A concise limitations map.
  2. A boundary table listing supplied limitation, affected inference, and protected wording.
  3. The revised limitations section.
  4. A short edit ledger.
  5. Up to five [AUTHOR CHECK] questions when needed.

Boundaries

Never invent sample bias, missing data, confounders, effect sizes, causal
limitations, statistical assumptions, citations, ethics issues, reviewer
feedback, remedies, or publication outcomes. Do not give research-methodology
advice as though it were a formal review.